Crash sparks fear,
search for safer flight
|
![]() ![]() |
CHRIS MORRIS
PEGGYS COVE, N.S. (CP) - The worst part of flying for Miles Gerety is the emergency
procedures demonstration. The point at which the flight attendant shows passengers how to
use life preservers acts as a trigger for Geretys emotions and the 48-year-old
Connecticut lawyer begins to cry quietly.
Gerety lost his older brother, Pierce, on Sept. 2 when Swissair Flight 111 plunged into
St. Margarets Bay off this scenic Nova Scotia cove, killing all 229 people on board.
He has since organized a support group to help families and friends of the victims cope
with their loss.
Gerety says fear of flying is one of the most common, lingering effects of the crash,
especially for children who lost relatives.
"I think for many people, fear of flying will be something they face the rest of
their lives," he says.
"But for me, and I know for other family members Ive since flown with,
its the emotional pain of wondering, What did they go through?
Thats indescribably tough."
The final moments of Flight 111 are the subject of intense investigation by Canadas
Transportation Safety Board, which is
trying to find out what went wrong on board the three-engine, wide-bodied MD-11 during a
regularly scheduled flight from New York to Geneva.
What is known is that over a period of time lasting roughly 20 minutes there was an
escalating emergency in the jetliner,
beginning when pilots detected smoke in the cockpit and ending when the plane plummeted
into the ocean off Peggys Cove.
Investigators know there was heat and smoke in the forward section of the plane. Some
experts speculate it was so hot, the pilot and co-pilot would have been forced out of the
cockpit.
Evidence of electrical arcing was found in damaged wiring recovered from the wreckage, a
phenomenon in which electricity flashes like lightning, vaporizing everything in its
blazing hot path.
Its also known that one of the three engines wasnt operating before the crash
- the one in the tail - and that the flight data
recorder and the cockpit voice recorder stopped working six minutes before the end,
pointing to massive electrical failure.
It could be as much as two years, maybe more, before the safety board has any hard
answers.
Thats fine with Gerety.
"I think I speak for the majority of family members when I say we would much rather
have a slow, thorough, scientific process than a quick answer we could never trust,"
he says.
"Its important to get it right."
Its important for more than the grieving families.
International air travel is speeding into an era of phenomenal growth and change, spurred
by technological improvements and an increasingly mobile population.
But devastating crashes like Swissair off Nova Scotia, the TWA explosion off Long Island,
N.Y., and the Valujet disaster in the Florida Everglades - all within the last three years
- have raised disturbing questions about the safety of air travel.
Jim Burin of the Flight Safety Foundation in Alexandria, Va., a non-profit international
group dedicated to improving air safety, says the accident rate has been holding steady
over the last five to eight years.
He doesnt think flying is becoming more dangerous, or less dangerous, and
thats the difficulty.
"The problem is that in the next 10 to 15 years, were looking at probably a 50
to 80 per cent increase in aviation traffic," Burin says.
"So the problem is if we keep the same rate but we increase the volume that much,
were going to have more accidents . . . In fact 50 years from now, if the
projections for traffic increases hold true, we could be seeing an accident a week."
Burin says the airline industry and its regulators are keenly aware that the spectacle of
so many crashes would deeply concern the traveling public.
"Everyone is working really hard at getting the rate down," he says.
The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration has launched a safer skies program that includes
close examination of older airplanes and of aging airplane components, such as electrical
and hydraulic systems.
"The new emphasis of a lot of the current safety initiatives, safer skies and some
others, is not necessarily reacting to the last accident, which we tend to do very
well," Burin says.
"But rather look at past accidents and incidents, look at overall trends and base our
focus on the actual data."
Investigators have recovered over 85 per cent of the Swissair jet from the the bottom of
St. Margarets Bay. They hope to reconstruct the cockpit.
Since a faulty
electrical system appears to have been the source of smoke detected by the pilots,
measures have been taken to inspect wiring on MD-11 airplanes. Curiously, despite all the high-tech gear on modern airliners, the doomed Swissair pilots had to rely on their own senses to identify the first sign of trouble - they smelled smoke. The FAA acknowledges that not enough attention has been paid to the potentially devastating impact of faulty wiring on airplanes. "There is currently no systematic process to identify and address potential catastrophic failures caused by electrical faults of wiring systems, aside from accident investigation-associated activities," the U.S. regulator recently admitted. |
Scorched wires from the wreckage included some that powered the planes in-flight
entertainment system. The system has
since been disconnected by Swissair.
Around the world, pilots appear to have become more alert to smoke-related problems and
are quick to land when smoke is detected.
Meanwhile, Gerety says mid-January will be a critical time for families of the victims.
Around Jan. 15, the RCMP will shut down its Family Contact Office at Canadian Forces Base
Shearwater, near Halifax,
where officers helped the coroner identify the shattered remains of victims.
The recovery and identification process is complete and families that have not already
done so now can make preparations to bring home remains of their relatives.
Gerety said some people will travel to Halifax because they dont want their loved
ones to come home alone.
"Jan. 15 seems to be kind of an end point for us, at least in terms of
identification," says Gerety, whose brother has been
identified but whose remains have yet to be returned.
"Those are the kinds of things were focusing on now."
© The Canadian Press, 1998