APPENDIX B: LEARNED HELPLESSNESS

Extract From a Letter by Inmate X

"...There is something else I want to share with you,...Learned Helplessness: The New Prisoners Dilemma

I have been incarcerated since [the early 190s] and have observed many changes in the treatment and attitude or prisoners. During my incarceration I have been fortunate enough to earn a 4 year degree in psychology from xxx University. And at the xxx where I was housed for 11 years, there was a psychiatric unit and I moderated a peer counseling program, for 10 years in which there were several men with emotional and personality disorders. I tell you this so you will know that I have some understanding of human behavior.

I know that you...are very much aware of the abuses by prison guards that have come to light, arranged by "Gladiator fights," beating and killing prisoners with impunity, and the cover ups. And just Jews were dehumanized and vilified in Nazi Germany 60 years ago, so are lifers being dehumanized and vilified in California today.

When I was first incarcerated...there was a different attitude among prisoners and guards than there is today. Firstly, life prisoners were being rewarded with parole for positive programming; secondly, the "CDC Inmate Appeal (CDC 602) system worked. But today, virtually no life term prisoners are being paroled, and the CDC 602 system no longer works and guards get away with abuses.

"In the 70s and 80s, the appeal process worked and when it failed and the prisoner was right the courts righted the wrong. A prisoner is wronged, files a 602 supporting his claim with facts and CDC regulations and the 602 is denied, or "partially granted," whatever that means. The California courts have become so conservative that there are no published opinions favorable to prisoners since the early 80s. After being wronged a few times, and the prisoner not being able to right the wrong through the proper channels, he soon learns that no matter what he does it will not change things, and he gives up and quits trying; learned helplessness sets in. What will be the long-term impact on these prisoners and society as men are released back into society with learned helplessness?

"And greater still are the mood swings life prisoners go through doing everything we are told to do then being denied parole and the parole board blatantly violating the law in its operation. And we have to watch men who are not doing life, leave and return, sometimes 4 or 5 times, because they don't know how to live in a free society. It is torture, but we somehow keep on keeping on, and I think that says something about the character of many of us lifers. I have watched, and experienced myself, severe mood swings. As life term prisoners who have committed a paroleable crime and are eligible for parole, learned helplessness has affected us in ways I never thought possible...

Return to Tim Leon's Home Page